Ooni’s two 16-inch pizza ovens look similar and cost similar money — but one burns gas and the other burns whatever you feed it. Here’s how to choose.
The short answer
Buy the Karu 16 if you want wood-fired flavor and don’t mind tending a fire. Buy the Koda 16 if you want pizza on a Tuesday night with zero fuss. Flavor versus convenience — that’s the whole decision.
Verdict: Karu for wood-fired flavor; Koda for push-button weeknight pizzas.
Side by side
| Spec | Koda 16 | Karu 16 |
|---|---|---|
| Fuel | Gas only | Wood, charcoal, or gas* |
| Max temp | 950°F | 950°F |
| Heat-up time | ~20 min | ~25 min (wood) |
| Pizza size | 16-inch | 16-inch |
| Cook time | ~90 seconds | ~90 seconds |
| Street price | ~$599 | ~$799 |
*Karu 16 burns wood and charcoal out of the box; the gas burner attachment is sold separately (~$100).
Flavor: Karu wins, and it’s not close
Wood smoke adds a subtle smokiness and better char spotting that gas can’t replicate — that’s the fundamental difference between the two fuels, and the reason flavor obsessives choose wood. Gas is clean and consistent, but it can’t fake wood smoke.
That said — the Koda’s pizza is still excellent. A Koda margherita beats most delivery pizza. You’re choosing between great and transcendent.
Convenience: Koda wins, and it’s not close
The Koda lights with a click, holds temp with a dial, and shuts off when you’re done — minutes of active effort, not an evening of fire management.
The Karu needs fire management all evening: building the fire, feeding it between pizzas, managing the coal bed. It’s fun — but on a busy weeknight, the Karu stays covered and you order in. The Koda gets used.
Be honest about which person you are. The best pizza oven is the one you’ll actually fire up.
The multi-fuel question
The Karu’s headline feature is burning wood, charcoal, or gas. The flexibility is nice on paper, but be honest with yourself: will you actually switch fuels? If not, don’t pay $200 extra for the option — pick the fuel you’ll use and commit.
Dough matters more than the oven
Whichever you buy, your pizza will only be as good as your dough. Dial in your recipe with our pizza dough calculator before you blame the oven.
Bottom line
Karu 16: for the enthusiast who wants the best possible pizza and enjoys fire. Koda 16: for everyone else — and there’s no shame in it. Weeknight pizza you actually make beats aspirational pizza you don’t.
Pitmaster Path is reader-supported. When we add buying links, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.